Lara Jean’s past and present collide when a boy from her past re-enters her life. She’s left juggling her feelings for both Peter and John, until she’s ultimately forced to decide which boy she wants in her future.
I found P.S. I Still Love You to be rather underwhelming. The characters still felt very two-dimensional.
In To All the Boys I’ve Loved Before I found myself really liking Peter, but in this book that all gets thrown out the window. The romance between Peter and Lara Jean is lacking. I couldn’t understand why they like each other, it seems like all they ever do is argue.
I really liked John. I feel like he put in a lot more effort to show his feeling for Lara Jean than Peter ever did. The relationship/friendship between John and Lara Jean was a lot more believable and felt way more genuine.
I don’t want to give away the ending but I will say, I didn’t like how it ended. The ending went in a completely different direction than I thought it should have, it didn’t feel natural.
My Rating: 2/5